Share, Research, Rate: Watches & Collections
v7.3 (A.I. Watch & Collection Reviews)
Follow for Updates:
3 - Hamilton / Sinn / Seiko - 202409270231
beardtamer
Collector:
Collector Description
[SOTC] One for Land, Air, and Sea.
These three are now my main collection. i was thinking of just keeping it a twosome which was my Sinn and my SPB213... but I found a deal that I could not pass on for a bronze khaki field mechanical, which I've always thought about buying.
I think I have a thing for tool watches though... Can't complain. I do also have a casio DB in gold, and an old Vario handwind with a red dial that my wife got me like 5 years ago.
Let me know what you think, or what you would add.
A.I. Watch Collection Review
8.7
### **5 Watch - Hamilton (33%) / Sinn (33%) / Seiko (33%) Collection Review by A.I. WatchMetrics**
---
### **Collection Type by Style:**
- **Field:** 33% Hamilton Khaki Field Mechanical Bronze
- **Diver:** 33% Seiko Prospex Sea SPB213
- **Sport:** 33% Sinn 556i
---
### **Collection Type by Movement:**
- **Automatic:** 67% Sinn 556i, Seiko Prospex Sea SPB213
- **Manual:** 33% Hamilton Khaki Field Mechanical Bronze
---
### **Overall Collection Rating: 8.7/10**
This collection showcases a solid balance between field, sport, and diver styles, with excellent exposure to durable and reliable movements. It reflects the profile of a collector who appreciates both rugged functionality and timeless design, with a slight leaning toward watches suited for active, outdoor lifestyles.
---
### **Breakdown by Watch Collection Metrics:**
- **Brand - Rating 8.5/10 (Weight: 10%)**
The collection includes highly reputable brands, with Hamilton, Sinn, and Seiko all having strong followings and proven histories of quality. These are not top-tier luxury brands, but they each excel in their respective categories and are highly respected by enthusiasts.
- **History & Innovation - Rating 8.0/10 (Weight: 10%)**
While the brands represented are known for innovation in specific areas, this collection leans more toward time-tested designs than breakthrough advancements. Sinn's history of tool watches and Seiko’s innovations in diving technology elevate the collection’s historical significance.
- **Rarity - Rating 7.8/10 (Weight: 10%)**
None of the pieces in this collection are particularly rare or limited, but they all possess a degree of desirability due to their reputation and practical appeal. The Hamilton Khaki Field Bronze offers a unique case material, which gives it a slight edge in rarity.
- **Material - Rating 8.5/10 (Weight: 10%)**
With stainless steel and bronze cases, along with sapphire crystals, the materials used across the collection are high-quality and durable. The bronze case of the Hamilton Khaki Field adds a distinctive touch.
- **Movement - Rating 8.5/10 (Weight: 10%)**
The movements in this collection are reliable and robust, with the manual-wind in the Hamilton Khaki and automatic movements in the Sinn 556i and Seiko SPB213. While these movements are workhorses, they are not particularly complex or high-end, which slightly lowers the rating.
- **Versatility - Rating 8.8/10 (Weight: 10%)**
The collection offers a range of versatility, from field and sports watches to a diver, making it suitable for both casual and active settings. These watches can easily transition from outdoor adventures to daily wear, although none of them are particularly suited for formal occasions.
- **Complications - Rating 7.5/10 (Weight: 10%)**
This collection features minimal complications, mostly limited to date functions. None of the watches have additional complications like chronographs or GMT functions, which reduces the overall rating.
- **Functions - Rating 9.0/10 (Weight: 10%)**
Each watch excels in its intended function. The Seiko Prospex SPB213’s 200-meter water resistance and the Sinn 556i’s 100-meter resistance make them excellent for diving and water-related activities, while the Hamilton Khaki Field is a simple, rugged field watch. Lume and overall legibility are high across the board.
- **Dials & Design - Rating 8.5/10 (Weight: 10%)**
The collection features clean, functional designs that prioritize legibility and practicality. The Sinn 556i is known for its no-nonsense dial, while the Seiko SPB213 brings a bit of flair with its blue dial and gold accents. The bronze Hamilton adds a vintage touch to the mix.
- **Cohesiveness - Rating 8.7/10 (Weight: 10%)**
Though the watches span different styles (field, diver, and sport), they are united by their robust, functional designs. Each watch serves a distinct purpose, yet they all share a rugged appeal and practical design philosophy, creating a cohesive collection.
---
### **Collection Strengths:**
- **Strong Utility**: Each watch excels in practical use, whether for diving, outdoor activities, or daily wear.
- **Material Variety**: The use of stainless steel and bronze adds material diversity while maintaining durability.
- **Great Brand Balance**: The collection features respected and popular mid-tier brands, offering high-quality without entering luxury price points.
---
### **Potential Ways for Improvement:**
- **Add a Complication**: Incorporating a watch with more complications, like a GMT or chronograph, would add complexity to the collection.
- **Expand Formal Options**: Including a more refined dress watch would balance the collection, allowing for more versatility in formal settings.
---
### **Watch by Watch Summary:**
1. **Hamilton Khaki Field Mechanical Bronze (8.5/10)**
- **Brand (8.5)**, **History & Innovation (8.0)**, **Rarity (8.0)**, **Material (8.5)**, **Movement (8.0)**, **Complications (6.0)**, **Functions (8.5)**, **Dials & Design (8.5)**, **Versatility (8.5)**, **Cohesiveness (8.7)**
- A rugged field watch with manual winding and a bronze case that develops a patina over time, adding character. Its design is simple and functional, and while not highly complex, it is a solid addition for any collector looking for a reliable field watch with a vintage touch.
2. **Sinn 556i (8.7/10)**
- **Brand (8.7)**, **History & Innovation (8.5)**, **Rarity (7.5)**, **Material (8.5)**, **Movement (8.5)**, **Complications (6.0)**, **Functions (9.0)**, **Dials & Design (8.7)**, **Versatility (8.8)**, **Cohesiveness (8.5)**
- This minimalist sport watch from Sinn is well-loved for its simplicity and durability. Its 100m water resistance, no-date dial, and clean design make it a versatile option for daily wear or sport activities.
3. **Seiko Prospex Sea SPB213 (8.7/10)**
- **Brand (8.5)**, **History & Innovation (8.0)**, **Rarity (7.5)**, **Material (8.5)**, **Movement (8.2)**, **Complications (7.5)**, **Functions (9.5)**, **Dials & Design (9.0)**, **Versatility (8.8)**, **Cohesiveness (8.7)**
- A well-executed diver with 200m water resistance, sapphire crystal, and Seiko’s in-house 6R35 movement. It combines Seiko’s dive watch legacy with modern aesthetics, making it a great all-rounder for water activities and casual wear.
---
### **Footnote:**
*A.I. WatchMetrics Review v6.20 - Sept 26, 2024*